TH Regrets The System of Popular Voting in Talent Show

From the motion i will give you positive and negative argument about this motion. (i’m sorry my english so bad)
As we know now so many reality program talent show. From singing program, miss universe, until preacher’s program. It’s so dificult for us to give vote one by one from viewer manually. And viewer want to give their vote for their idol on that talent show. So organizer cooperate with provider’s operator to provide convenience to the audience to give their vote to their idol by sending sort message. But it didn’t escape the positive and negative impacts to the supporters and organizers. The positive impact of voting system is

1. Give Benefit to Operator
Voting system in Indonesia, mostly using sms. Everyone is free to give as much support to their idol contestants. But the sms rates to support it is not cheap. It is very expensive. With premium SMS rates, Rp.2200/sms. With 50% of the gain operator then this is a huge advantage for the organizers. Each audience would want to be a winner of his idol, then they simply continue to send the sms to support his idol. One person can send sms decades overnight, try to imagine how many supportes send sms that their idol not eliminated from talent show. For example from 10 contestants their have one supporter, and their supporter send one sms for vote their idol. So, we get 10 sms from supporter, 50% for provider and 50% for organizer. A sms we get Rp.1000, so organizer get Rp.10.000 from 10 supporter.

2. Audience can Choose The Winner which they want.
From the event talent show their provide give facilities for the audience to support her idol by sending sms. After we watch our idol appearance on television we can send as many sms-much so that our idols are not eliminated from the talent show event. Indirectly audience that determine who will be the winner in the show is taken from a talent show who has the most to get sms’s polling of viewers at home.
For example i love Fathin Sidqia on talent Show X-Factor, everyweek i watch television for watching performance fathin on television. I love performance fathin Sidqia so much, and i won’t Fathin eliminated from X-Factor. So i send sms for vote Fathin and inderectly i and other fans choose Fathin to be a winner on X-Factor.

3. Increase Contestant’s Spirit
In talent show in Indonesia audience can voting their idol anytime, anywhere. Contestant’s can eliminated by the lowest voting sms their get. Because contestant’s worried get a little voting, so they try to give best performance every their appearance. They won’t lost with another contestant. It is can increase contestan’t spirit on every their performance. For example, on the program talent show have 10 contestant, and everyweek they competing for get many vote from audience. She won’t eliminated from that talent show, so fight it out for the audience give vote to her by she get the best performance everyweek, she give show new ideas on their performance for audience keep voting them and she can to be a winner on that talent show program. for example if we working in a factory, and boss appraise us, so we try to work as closely as possible.

4. Survey how many society interest to this program and contestant
Choosing the winner in talent show by voting can survey how many society interest to this program. if many voting for contestant in this program, it’s mean many people watch this program. if many people watch this program, it’s mean many people interest to this program. for example, we sell a product, and we sell it to the market. we noticed that many who buy the product or not. if many were purchased, meaning a lot of people who love our products. If just a little people buy our product, so only a few who like us product.

Because the system of voting sms can give benefit to operator, audience can choose the winner which they want, increase contestant’s spirit and can survey how many society interest to this program and contestant, so we can’t regrats the system of popular voting in talent show.

And this is the negative side from system of voting on talent show

1. incurring a debt to the family.
voting system in the talent show make contestants and their family as hard as possible to get as much of the voting audience. this raises cheating among the contestants. The contestants family willing to do anything to profess their family members to be a winner in the talent show. One of many way is free pulse to surrounding so that they give support the contestants by sending sms. not infrequently a lot of families who are willing to go into debt to buy and distribute pulses to get a lot of support. it is not fair, because the rich could have been more fortunate than the poor because they can provide more support to the contestants by giving pulse to th other for voting the contestant. For example we want new phone, we will working hardly to get money for buy new handphone. But not infrequently also indebted to anyone willing to buy a new phone.
2. Appraisement not Objectif
by voting sms viewers at home could support anyone without the ability to know what the talent contestants. Could have the support of a beautiful watch, white skin, or perhaps their relatives, regardless of whether or not they look good. This is not fair because if in the singing contest should be judged is the voice, not the pretty or the other. For example, we will buy new phone, so we must appraise phone by the fiture, spesification and application phone’s has. Not just from outward appearance.

3. Usefulness of Jury
In talent show program there is always a jury for appraise performance of contestant. But so many in talent show use the system of voting to determined the winner. In here the role of jury not maximum. Because in every performance, contestant get input fro the jury and jury judges commented on the action, but keep audience choosing who can to be a winner. whereas a jury know deficiency and excess from contestant, whether or not the appearance of the contestants, and jury understand more about music (in musical events) than the audiences who judge only through physical and most do not know about music. For example we want to make a cake, so we must ask the expert chefs who make cakes. Not not to a tailor who can only know the food was good or not without knowing the recipe and what is missing from the cake.

Because system of voting can make incurring a debt to the family, Appraisement not Objectif, Usefulness of Jury, so we regrets the system of popular voting in talent show.